Your Business – From a Buyer’s Point of View

IMG_8865-001

When you sell your business, you want to do everything possible to get the right price. That often means forgetting about how you have run the business, and looking at it from the buyer’s point of view.

What the Buyer is Buying

Generally speaking, a buyer will be willing to pay a price that is a multiple of the company’s annual cash flow. The multiple varies widely depending on the industry, the economy and many other factors. The price the buyer pays, though, will be a multiple of his expected cash flow – not yours.

The harsh fact is that the buyer doesn’t care how you ran the business. Certainly, he will keep what he sees as the best practices and procedures, and will probably keep most of your people, but his ideas on executive compensation, business development, human resources, inventory control, and a host of other subjects will probably differ from yours.

I actually saw a deal fall apart because the seller insisted on dictating how the business would be operated AFTER he was gone.

The trick is to know what the buyer believes he is buying.

Normalizing Results

It’s a useful exercise to adjust historical earnings for unique, unusual or non-recurring items, so future cash flow projections reflect the results the buyer is likely to achieve. This is called “normalizing” cash flow. Depending on how you’ve been operating the business, this process may identify certain assets or liabilities that should be valued separately.

Here are some examples:

Owner’s Compensation

A homebuilder’s owner paid himself a salary that was much higher than the CEO of any similar company would normally receive. It was his decision as to whether he wanted to receive the funds as salary or as a draw against earnings, but it did cause widespread resentment within the company, especially during lean times.

The important point here, though, is that by adding back the excess owner’s compensation into the cash flow projections, the company’s value increased by a multiple of say, 6 or 7 times that amount.

Below-Market Rents

A retailer had been in business for many years, and was such a desirable tenant that it could drive a very hard bargain with landlords. It was common to find 20 year leases at below-market rates, with 10-year extensions. A careful reading of the lease on the ideally-located head office revealed that it ran in perpetuity.

The low rents increased the company’s cash flow, and would have been taken into account if the company had been valued strictly on a multiple of that cash flow. Valuing leases uses much the same arithmetic as arriving at a multiple of earnings, but the terms of these leases were so unusual that we saw the need to evaluate them as a separate asset.

Ultimately, we prepared cash flow projections using much higher market-rate rents. This reduced the amount a buyer would pay for the company based on its projected cash flows, but it was more than made up by the higher value assigned to the leases as a separate asset.

Unusual Expenses

The owner of another company had a unique set of personal beliefs, and insisted that all of his employees and vendors share or participate in them – at considerable cost. Everyone was required to attend expensive week-long seminars by a California-based consultant who taught them how to deal with their personal fears. Another consultant was flown in from San Francisco for a week to realign the chakras of the executive staff. The owner catered lunches several times a week, so the entire staff would attend his meditation sessions. The company sponsored a project in which meditation experts gathered in Sedona to effect world peace.

It was highly unlikely that a buyer would continue these human resource policies, so we added back their cost to normalized cash flow, and substantially increased the asking price of the company.

Historic Land Values

A land developer and homebuilder had been in business for many years, and owned properties it had purchased up to 30 years previously. The profit margins on the houses it sold were significantly higher than they would have been if the land were acquired more recently.

There had been talk within the company of separating the land component of the business from the homebuilding component, in order to clearly see where the profit and returns on investment really came from, but the initiative never got off the ground.

The low historic land values were reflected in profits, but not in the actual operating cash flows, so a valuation based on a multiple of cash flow didn’t make sense. We prepared normalized cash flow projections for the homebuilding business based on market prices for the land, and did a separate valuation of the land reserves, based on those same market prices.

Non-Recurring Costs

Most companies have expenses they needed to incur a single time, or for a limited period. Examples I have seen include legal fees and settlement costs for lawsuits, discretionary bonuses for unusual personal or company performance and employee termination costs. I worked with a company that had incurred huge expenses trying to start a new line of business that was never realized. Another committed to a year-long sponsorship of a local sports team in a marketing effort that was judged a failure.

None of these costs can be expected to be repeated by a buyer of the company, and so should be added back to the normalized historic earnings, and to the cash flow projections used to place a value on the company.

Does your CFO understand the value of normalizing your cash flows from a buyer’s point of view?

Advertisement

Valuing a Consulting Business

IMG_7725-003

 

There are probably hundreds of reasons why you might contemplate selling your consulting business. Among them would be retirement, changing markets, illness or just the urge to move on and do something new.

Who is the buyer?

The buyer will probably be another consultant – either a competitor or a firm with a desire to expand their offering to include your area of expertise. It is unlikely that there will be financiers, or others with no direct experience standing in line to buy your business. There is, however, a pretty good chance the buyer will be a partner or an employee, in which case you need to start talking to financial planners long before you expect to do the transaction.

What are they buying?

When you think of selling the business, you tend to think of it as just that… the business. When we start thinking about its value, though, it is a good idea to put ourselves in the buyer’s position. What specifically does the buyer hope to acquire?

–          Your client list / existing relationships.

–          Expertise in a new field, or the opportunity to serve a backlog of client demand.

–          Name and reputation.

–          An instant start in the business with a functioning team – it saves the time, energy and uncertainty of building the business from scratch… as long as the cost isn’t too high.

–          Ability to leverage your client base – the buyer can provide services from your business to his existing clients, or alternatively, sell new services to your current clients.

–          Owner to stay on through a transition period – to facilitate the smooth transfer of relationships, retention of staff, transfer of knowledge and expertise.

What is the price?

Consulting firms typically have relatively little in the way of assets, so one way or another, the selling price is likely to be a multiple of earnings or cash flow. EBITDA (earnings before interest, depreciation and amortization) is a traditional measurement of cash flow, but why not add back your salary and any special items such as health care and travel that could be considered personal, and would not be costs to the company after the sale? Also consider accounting, legal, insurance etc. costs that will go away after the acquisition.

The value of a single-person operation will probably be lower because of the impracticality of having the seller stay on through a transition period, and the higher risk of losing clients.

The purchase price will depend on the exact fit with the buyer’s business, and the time and cost of entering the field. Remember that if you ask too high a price, the buyer may decide to start the business from scratch, maybe even hiring your best employees away from you, and competing for your existing clients.

Rules of thumb – selling prices generally fall between 2.5 and 3.5 times earnings (high utilization rates and low costs will result in a higher value) OR .75 to 1.25 times gross revenue, which probably yields the same value, depending on your profit margins.

The purchase price will be higher if you stay on through a transition period. You would draw a salary, of course, and it doesn’t hurt to be there to keep an eye on your payout.

Payment Structure

You’ll get the highest price if it is paid out over time, say 2 – 3 years. An up-front payment in the range of 25% is common.

Remember that if a buyer pays 3 times earnings up front, he will get no return on his investment for 3 years, a situation that few investors can tolerate. Even if there are synergies that result in additional business, the buyer would probably have to lay out additional investment to realize them.

 

Do you know who to call if you need help selling your business?

 

How Much Is It Worth? Uh… What? And to Whom?

008

Many business owners are thinking it may be time for a change. And everyone has a different set of concerns.

– Do you really want the hassle of doing it all over again through the next business cycle?
– Is there enough cash to retire or move on to the next venture?
– Do you need cash now, or can you take it over time?
– Do you want to get out from under the personal guarantees?
– Continuity of the business.
– Welfare of managers and employees.
– Do you want to have an ongoing management role?

What Are You Selling?

Assets – You can sell off assets, pay off debt, and keep the difference. Selling to an opportunistic buyer would be quicker, but the price will be lower in the amount of their profit.

An Ongoing Business – Solid, predictable cash flows can be multiplied at an appropriate rate to calculate a selling price, and to set a time horizon.

A Business Plan – If it is already under way, you may be able to use projected cash flows to increase the selling price.

Your Wisdom and Expertise – This could justify an ongoing management or consulting role.

Who’s Buying?

Nobody – An orderly shut-down and sale of assets.

Financiers – Maybe, but only if the price is really, really right.

Employees or Family Members – They have a stake in continuing the business. This could take several years to accomplish.

Someone in the Industry – Someone who has an interest in entering or expanding in your market.

Each of these situations will have a very different value and personal outcome for yourself and your family.

Does your CFO have the knowledge and experience to advise you on a business exit strategy?